Be Valiant

Dr. Lily Kurtz

Who Is Your Athlete Beyond Their Sport?

When Being an Athlete Becomes Who You Are

Who is your athlete when the game is over? For many young athletes, sports are more than an activity. They shape friendships, daily routines, confidence, belonging, and eventually the way a child sees themselves. In this episode of Be Valiant, Todd Merkow sits down with Dr. Lily Kurtz — a board-certified psychiatric nurse practitioner, former collegiate swimmer at Tufts University, and advocate for athlete mental health — to explore how athletic identity develops and what happens when that identity is challenged.

The identity sports give us

Sports offer young people something powerful: a place to belong. A child joins a team, wears the uniform, builds friendships, learns routines, and begins working toward goals. Over time, those experiences can become central to how they describe themselves. Dr. Kurtz explains that sports can provide a ready-made identity at a developmental stage when young people are still discovering who they are. That identity can be positive — athletic commitment can build confidence, connection, discipline, and purpose. The concern isn't that a child strongly identifies as an athlete. It's what happens when other parts of their identity receive little opportunity to develop.

When the pathway becomes the identity

Dr. Kurtz recalls the pressure she experienced while pursuing collegiate swimming. Although she ultimately attended Tufts University, she initially felt embarrassed about choosing a Division III program while many of her peers were headed to Division I schools. Her experience raises an important question for sports parents: when did the level of competition become a measure of an athlete's value? A young athlete can begin to believe that a particular scholarship, roster position, ranking, or college division determines whether years of commitment were worthwhile.

Dr. Kurtz also introduces identity foreclosure, a concept from psychologist James Marcia's work on identity development. Identity foreclosure occurs when someone commits to an identity or future without sufficiently exploring other possibilities. Importantly, dedication to a sport does not automatically mean identity foreclosure. An athlete can be deeply committed while maintaining meaningful interests, relationships, and goals outside competition. The distinction parents should consider is whether their child feels free to explore who they are — or feels obligated to maintain an identity that others expect.

What happens when sports suddenly stop?

Dr. Kurtz experienced an abrupt disruption when the COVID-19 pandemic ended her collegiate swimming season shortly before the Division III national championships. She describes how disorienting that experience was, not only for herself but for athletes whose schedules, communities, and goals suddenly disappeared. This experience helped shape her interest in athletic identity, transitions, and mental health. For sports parents, the lesson extends well beyond college athletics. An injury, reduced playing time, a difficult coaching relationship, being cut from a team, or finishing a final high school season can challenge an athlete's sense of self. The transition doesn't have to involve a professional career to matter deeply.

The influence of parents and coaches

Parents and coaches can unintentionally reinforce the idea that performance determines personal worth. When conversations focus primarily on results, playing time, rankings, and achievements, young athletes may begin to associate approval and belonging with how well they perform. Dr. Kurtz encourages parents to shift more attention toward enjoyment, relationships, and personal qualities unrelated to athletic achievement. She also emphasizes the importance of understanding how children feel around their coaches. Do they feel supported? Challenged constructively? Comfortable making mistakes? Those questions can reveal experiences that performance statistics never will.

A bad game, reduced playing time, or disappointing result should not determine how an athlete feels about their value as a person.

Editorial takeaway

Building more than one stepping stone

One of Dr. Kurtz's most memorable explanations involves stepping stones. Imagine standing in water with only one stone beneath you. If that stone becomes unstable, maintaining your balance becomes difficult. Now imagine having several stones. For a young athlete, those additional stones may represent friendships, family, creative interests, academic pursuits, community, and experiences unrelated to sports. When an athletic setback occurs, the child has other meaningful sources of confidence and belonging. The goal is not to diminish sports. It's to ensure that sports do not have to carry the entire weight of a young person's identity.

Preparing for life beyond the game

Dr. Kurtz emphasizes that transitions deserve support before, during, and after they occur. Parents can help by creating opportunities for exploration, maintaining open conversations, and recognizing changes in mood, confidence, or social engagement. When distress persists or begins affecting everyday life, professional mental health support may be appropriate. The most important message is not that athletes should care less about sports. It's that they deserve to know they are valued for far more than what they accomplish in competition.

Top 5 Takeaways

1

A STRONG ATHLETIC IDENTITY ISN'T AUTOMATICALLY UNHEALTHY.

Sports can provide belonging, purpose, confidence, and community. Problems can arise when athletic performance becomes the primary measure of personal value.

2

IDENTITY FORECLOSURE CAN BEGIN EARLIER THAN PARENTS REALIZE.

Young athletes may commit to a single identity or future before exploring other interests, relationships, and possibilities. Parents can support commitment while preserving opportunities for exploration.

3

ACHIEVEMENT AND SELF-WORTH SHOULD NOT BECOME INTERCHANGEABLE.

A bad game, reduced playing time, or disappointing result should not determine how an athlete feels about their value as a person.

4

PARENTS AND COACHES INFLUENCE HOW ATHLETES SEE THEMSELVES.

The language adults use, the expectations they establish, and the environments they create can reinforce either performance-dependent worth or a broader sense of belonging.

5

PREPARE FOR ATHLETIC TRANSITIONS BEFORE THEY HAPPEN.

Injuries, team changes, and the end of a sports career can disrupt identity. Building other sources of confidence and connection helps athletes navigate those changes.

THE GUEST LEAVE-BEHIND

The Valiant Parent Playbook

When a bad game affects your child for days, what should you recognize — and how can you respond?

Dr. Kurtz offers practical guidance for parents whose athlete's mood and confidence remain low after a disappointing performance.

PAY ATTENTION TO HOW LONG IT LASTS

Notice whether disappointment begins affecting school, relationships, or everyday functioning. Duration and impact are important signals.

RECONNECT WITH WHAT ISN'T ABOUT ACHIEVEMENT

Help your child spend time with family, enjoy an activity together, or explore an interest without any expectation of success. Belonging and support are not dependent on results.

RECOGNIZE QUALITIES BEYOND SPORTS

Name what you see in your child that has nothing to do with athletics — being a good friend, showing kindness, or caring for others. If low mood, withdrawal, or loss of confidence persists, consider connecting your child with an appropriate mental health professional.

Watch Be Valiant

Subscribe to our YouTube channel for video content, interviews, and the Be Valiant series.

Subscribe on YouTube

Join the Movement

Follow Valiant Sports Society for expert conversations, practical parenting insights, and trusted youth sports education delivered every week.

BE VALIANT.
PLAY FEARLESS.

Valiant Sports Society